May 2026
February 2026
- Feb 20, 2026Concepts4 Moral Frameworks That Explain Every Ethical DilemmaGreene's functional MRI work compared the lever trolley case with the footbridge variant, where you push a man to stop the trolley. Outcomes are structurally identical, but the personal version activated emotion-associated regions far more strongly and subjects refused it. Impersonal dilemmas pull toward consequentialism, personal ones toward deontology. This compares consequentialism, deontology, virtue ethics and care ethics, then tests them on Milgram and Nuremberg.
- Feb 19, 2026ConceptsRule-Based vs Principle-Based EthicsDworkin's distinction is the hinge: rules apply all-or-nothing, while principles state a reason that must be weighed against competing ones. The page sets out when each wins, traffic law and harassment policy against medical and journalism ethics, then six failure modes including rule proliferation, letter-not-spirit gaming, and principles vague enough that opposite actions both claim them. It closes on the layered hybrid.
July 2025
May 2025
- May 27, 2025CultureConsequentialism: When Outcomes Justify ActionsIf only results carry moral weight, no act is intrinsically wrong and rights become instruments rather than limits. Ford's internal Pinto analysis shows where that reasoning leads: the company priced a human life at $200,725, compared a roughly $137 million design fix against $49.5 million in expected liability, and declined the fix. Critics from Bernard Williams to John Rawls argue that aggregating welfare this way treats people as containers rather than persons.
- May 27, 2025CultureCare Ethics vs Justice Ethics: Key DifferencesAsked whether Heinz should steal medicine for his dying wife, many of Gilligan's subjects questioned the dilemma's constraints rather than ranking property against life, asking why Heinz could not talk to the pharmacist. Kohlberg's framework scored that as a lower stage. This page sets out both orientations on impartiality, rights, relationships and context, and reports honestly that later research found small gender differences at most, with men and women using both.
- May 27, 2025CultureVirtue Ethics ExplainedAristotle's answer to how a person should live, worked through eudaimonia, virtue as a mean between excess and deficiency, and phronesis as the master virtue without which courage becomes recklessness. The page traces the revival through Anscombe and MacIntyre, then weighs the evidence: Peterson and Seligman's 24 character strengths under six virtues found across traditions, and a meta-analysis putting moral identity's link to ethical behavior at r = .22.
- May 26, 2025CultureMoral Dilemmas: When All Options Seem WrongA 2019 review in the Journal of Traumatic Stress covering 116 studies concluded that moral injury cannot be reduced to post-traumatic stress. That fits Ruth Barcan Marcus's 1980 argument: the agent-regret lingering after an impossible choice is not confusion but a signal that something morally real was lost. Also covered: the trolley problem and dirty hands.
- May 26, 2025CultureDeontological Ethics: When Rules Come FirstDeontology treats some acts as wrong in themselves, which is why nearly everyone rejects killing one healthy person to transplant organs into five. Kant grounded this in the categorical imperative and in perfect duties admitting no exceptions, while W.D. Ross loosened it into seven prima facie duties that bind unless a weightier one overrides. Joshua Greene's fMRI work reads such judgments as evolved emotion, though critics reply that emotion may track real distinctions.
- May 24, 2025CultureMoral Luck: Ethics, Control, and JudgmentsThe only difference between the two drivers is whether a child happened to be in the street, yet one wakes with a hangover and the other faces vehicular manslaughter. That gap is the problem of moral luck, and it violates the control principle that we should be assessed only for what we control. This page works through Nagel's four categories, resultant, circumstantial, constitutive and causal, and the attempt-completion gap that embeds luck in criminal law.
- May 23, 2025CultureMoral Relativism vs. Moral UniversalismThe American Anthropological Association told the UN in 1947 that standards and values are relative to their culture; the Universal Declaration was adopted in 1948 regardless. The article separates descriptive, metaethical and normative relativism, shows relativism tripping over its own universal demand for tolerance, and maps the middle ground: Walzer's thin and thick morality, Berlin's pluralism, and Nussbaum's capabilities approach, which fixes what must be secured.
- May 22, 2025CultureUnderstanding Moral Progress and Its ChallengesKwame Anthony Appiah examined three moral revolutions and found a common mechanism in The Honor Code: the practices were abandoned because carrying on came to be associated with shame rather than honor, with the shift in what counted as respectable preceding the change. This page weighs that against the measurement problem, the contingency objection and new atrocities, and notes that Pinker's decline-of-violence case is disputed by Gray and Moyn.
March 2025
February 2025
June 2023
May 2022
No guides match that search. Try a shorter phrase, or clear the search.