HOME/WORK & SKILLS/LEADERSHIP

Culture is what leaders tolerate

Mission statements describe a culture; behaviour that goes unaddressed defines it. This topic starts where the evidence is strongest: how to recognise a toxic workplace and what to do about it.

1 ARTICLE · REVIEWED NOV 2026

10.4×

more predictive of attrition than pay

Toxic culture was the strongest predictor of people leaving during the Great Resignation, ahead of compensation.

SULL, SULL & ZWEIG · MIT SLOAN MANAGEMENT REVIEW · 2022

The toxic five

The attributes most predictive of a toxic culture in Sull and colleagues’ analysis of employee reviews. Leadership behaviour was the most consistent driver of all five.

  1. 01

    Disrespectful

    Lack of consideration, courtesy and dignity.

  2. 02

    Non-inclusive

    Unequal treatment by group; favouritism and cronyism.

  3. 03

    Unethical

    Dishonesty and lack of regulatory compliance.

  4. 04

    Cutthroat

    Colleagues actively undermine one another.

  5. 05

    Abusive

    Bullying, harassment and hostility from managers.

EARLY WARNING SIGNSSix things to watch for

  • Turnover concentrated in particular teams
  • Bad news only travels down; good news only travels up
  • Failures end in blame rather than a lesson
  • Rules applied differently depending on status
  • A high performer with a known pattern of complaints, unaddressed
  • People stop disagreeing in meetings

HOW TO RESPONDDepends on where you sit

If you work there

Document specific incidents with dates. Find allies and a skip-level or HR route. Decide your threshold for leaving before you reach it.

If you lead there

Act on the high performer first; tolerance is the loudest signal. Ask for anonymous feedback, and report the results back. Model admitting your own mistakes.

All twelve signs, with responses: Identifying Toxic Workplace Signs and Responses. More on leading teams: Management & Leadership.

Frequently asked questions

Sull's MIT Sloan research found leadership was consistently the best predictor, ahead of social norms and work design.

See Work & Skills › Management & Leadership for delegation, decisions and leading through uncertainty.

All 1 articles in this topic

1 ARTICLES · NEWEST FIRST

THE WEEKLY DISPATCH

Get smarter every week.

One new guide in your inbox each week, plus a note on which older guides were revised. Unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. No spam, ever.