Of all direct channels in digital marketing, email is the most dependable.[15] Organic reach on Facebook business pages fell below 5% by 2024 as social media algorithms cut your reach. SEO needs months to build up and the majority of websites never get to rank for competitive terms.

Paid ads stop the moment you stop paying, and customer acquisition costs on major ad platforms have increased over 300% since 2015. An email list is yours: you own the relationship, the addresses, and the ability to reach your audience whenever you have something worth saying.

Your strategy, revenue potential and the email marketing you end up doing all come down to the platform you use to manage that list. A tool made for retail promo emails will work against you if you try to build a creator funnel.

When you need sophisticated e-commerce automation, a tool built for newsletter operators will limit you. Choosing well is not only about features, but about which tool's design philosophy matches yours.

Mailchimp built its reputation as the friendly, accessible email marketing tool for small businesses. For a decade it was the default choice, the one with the chimp logo that appeared in virtually every small business newsletter.

ConvertKit entered the market in 2013 with a specific thesis: the tools available to creators were designed for businesses, and creators needed something different.

Beehiiv is the newest entrant, founded by people who built Morning Brew's newsletter infrastructure and who believe that a newsletter can be a standalone media business with its own monetisation model baked in from day one.

These three platforms represent three distinct visions of what email marketing is for. Mailchimp is for businesses sending marketing emails and campaigns. ConvertKit (now rebranding as Kit) is for creators building subscriber relationships and selling products.[12]

Newsletter operators who run a reader business should use Beehiiv. More important than comparing feature lists is grasping that distinction.

Your email platform is not just a sending tool. It is the infrastructure for the most personal relationship you have with your audience. Choose the one that matches your revenue model, not the one with the most recognisable brand.


Key Differences at a Glance

FeatureMailchimpConvertKit (Kit)Beehiiv
Free tier500 contacts, 1,000 emails/month10,000 subscribersUp to 2,500 subscribers
Paid plansFrom $13/month (500 contacts)Creator: $25/month (1k subs), Pro: $50Scale: $39/month, Max: $99/month
Subscriber modelContact-based (each email = one contact)Subscriber-basedSubscriber-based
AutomationsYes (Standard+)Visual builder, excellentBasic sequences
Landing pagesYesYesYes
Paid subscriptionsVia integrations onlyYes (Creator Pro+)Yes, native
Ad networkNoNoYes (native Beehiiv Boosts)
Referral programNoNoYes (native)
Newsletter analyticsStandardGoodAdvanced (newsletter-focused)
SegmentationYesTag-based, excellentGood
A/B testingYes (Essentials+)YesYes
Best forSmall businesses, e-commerceCreator funnels, course sellersNewsletter businesses
Integrations300+90+ (deep creator tool integrations)Growing (newer platform)
Deliverability reputationGoodVery goodExcellent

Why Email Still Dominates: The Data Behind the Channel

It is worth grounding the decision in why email marketing needs serious platform selection in the first place before comparing the tools.

Litmus's 2025 State of Email report says that email marketing brings in an average return of $36 for every $1 spent. That figure has held fairly steady even as costs of digital advertising have gone up.[13]

Mailchimp's own benchmark data shows that across industries the average email open rate is about 21.5%. But engaged creator and newsletter audiences can hit and commonly see open rates of 40 to 60%.[10]

List ownership is the decisive argument. Organic reach for a Facebook page with 100,000 followers goes to about 3,000 to 5,000 per post. An email list of 10,000 subscribers that has a 40% open rate gets 4,000 people who picked to read what you write.

When a platform algorithm changes, your social following can effectively disappear overnight. Email is immune to this. The list is yours regardless of what any platform decides.

Subscriber lifetime value. Builds up in ways that social followers do not. Someone who stays on your email list for three years and opens your content regularly is worth orders of magnitude more than a follower who saw two posts. Economics point toward developing an email relationship.

Which platform you build on determines whether you make use of these advantages or let them go untapped.


Pricing: List Size Economics and Where Each Platform Hurts

Mailchimp

Mailchimp bases its pricing on list size and costs rise quickly as your audience grows.[1] The free tier handles 500 contacts. Essentials costs $13/month starting at 500 contacts and scales by contact count. With 10,000 contacts, Essentials is about $80/month and at 50,000 contacts, the cost is $270+/month.

If a subscriber appears on multiple lists, Mailchimp counts them multiple times and historically this has resulted in higher billing for segmented audiences. That is a complaint that is documented well.

The practice of charging per contact on each list, rather than per unique subscriber, can make Mailchimp genuinely expensive for businesses with complex segmentation requirements where the same contact belongs to multiple audience segments.

Larger organisations get premium at $350/month base that comes with advanced segmentation, unlimited seats and priority support.

A useful illustration: a marketing agency managing separate lists for ten small business clients could be paying for the same contacts multiple times depending on how lists are structured. This is an architectural problem with Mailchimp's data model that persists despite years of user complaints.

ConvertKit (Kit)

Up to 10,000 subscribers come with unlimited email sends, a landing page builder and basic forms on ConvertKit's free plan, which is unusually generous.[4]

This is the most generous free tier of the three for growing lists, and it has been a significant customer acquisition tool - many creators built their first list on ConvertKit's free tier before upgrading.

The paid Creator plan begins at $25/month for up to 1,000 subscribers. That sounds odd at first because the free tier allows 10,000 subscribers, yet the difference lies in features: paid plans open up automation, priority support and access to the newsletter referral network.

Creator Pro at $50/month adds advanced reporting, Facebook custom audiences integration, and subscriber scoring.

Pricing on ConvertKit goes up as the number of subscribers grows.[2] The Creator Pro plan runs about $379 per month at 50,000 subscribers. That is costly for operators of large lists yet it reflects how willing the creator market is to pay for a tool that lines up with their specific workflows.

Whether the automations and creator-specific features justify the cost difference against alternatives at the same list size is the question that is always asked.

Beehiiv

Beehiiv started out with genuinely competitive pricing.[3] Up to 2,500 subscribers get core newsletter features in the free tier. Premium features open at $39/month on the Scale plan and Max at $99/month brings in full ad network access, custom domains on multiple publications and advanced segmentation.

Beehiiv's pricing model is notably different from Mailchimp's: it is flat-rate by tier rather than purely list-size-based at lower subscriber counts. A newsletter with 8,000 subscribers pays the same Scale rate as one with 1,000.

This makes costs predictable as you grow, which matters for newsletter operators who are trying to model revenue against expenses.

For newsletter operators in the 1,000 to 25,000 subscriber range, Beehiiv's pricing is often the most competitive of the three when you factor in the native monetisation features included in the plan price.

On Mailchimp or ConvertKit, those features (paid subscriptions, ad network access and referral programs) would need their own tools and the costs that go with them.


Automations: Where ConvertKit Leads

What sets apart a basic newsletter tool from a genuine marketing platform is email automation. Sending the right email to the right person at the right time, based on their behaviour and interests, is what makes email marketing scalable and grows in line with list size.

ConvertKit's Visual Automation Builder

ConvertKit's automation system is built around a tag-and-sequence model that is particularly well-suited to creators.[7] When a subscriber downloads a lead magnet, they get tagged and enter an automated sequence.

When they purchase a product, they get a different tag that triggers a different sequence. When they click a specific link, they get moved to a segment that receives more targeted content.

The visual automation builder lets you design these flows graphically - drag and drop triggers, conditions, and actions in a branching diagram.

A creator running an online course business, a membership community, and a free newsletter simultaneously can build automation sequences that manage the complexity of multiple subscriber journeys without requiring a developer or complex integration.

A practical example: a creator sells a $197 course on photography. When someone joins the free newsletter, they enter a 5-email welcome sequence. If they click the link about camera equipment in email 3, they get tagged as "gear-interested" and receive a separate 3-email sequence highlighting the course.

Once they purchase the course, they get taken out of the promotional sequence and put into the student onboarding sequence automatically. Multiple tools and custom integration on Mailchimp or major compromise on Beehiiv would be needed to set up this whole workflow built in ConvertKit.

Mailchimp's Customer Journey Builder

On the Standard plan, Mailchimp rolled out its Customer Journey builder. This gives a visual automation method comparable at a surface level to what ConvertKit offers.

It is functional and adequate for most business email automation: welcome sequences, abandoned cart emails for e-commerce, re-engagement campaigns, and promotional sequences.

For businesses using Mailchimp as a marketing tool connected to a Shopify or WooCommerce store, the e-commerce automation features are well-integrated.

Through the Mailchimp-Shopify integration, abandoned cart sequences, post-purchase follow-ups, product recommendations based on what customers have bought and win-back campaigns for people who have stopped buying all run reliably.

Mailchimp's automation mental model focuses on campaigns rather than on subscribers and this is its practical limit. The tool is built to send campaigns to lists and not to run individual subscriber journeys based on fine behavioral triggers and retail email works with this approach but creator use cases hit friction.

Beehiiv's Automation Limitations

Of the three, Beehiiv's automation features are the weakest. The platform takes care of basic welcome sequences and time-based drip campaigns but ConvertKit gives depth of conditional logic and behavioural automation that is not found in Beehiiv.

Consistently distributed great newsletter content to a growing audience is held to be more valuable than complex automation architecture and this is what the platform is explicitly built around.

Newsletter operators whose main approach is sending a strong newsletter and growing via content quality and referrals find this limitation minor. The only automation you really need is welcoming new subscribers, re-engaging inactive ones and delivering paid subscriber content.

Beehiiv handles these cases. For operators who want complex automated sales funnels, Beehiiv is the wrong tool and switching later will be painful.


Newsletter Monetisation: Beehiiv's Structural Advantage

This is where Beehiiv separates itself decisively from the other two platforms, and where the founding team's experience building Morning Brew's infrastructure is most visible.

Within the platform, Beehiiv has a native paid subscription system that newsletter operators can use to offer premium subscription tiers directly.[8] Setting up the system is simple. Create a paid tier, specify the price and payment processing goes through Stripe as well as subscriber management and content gating handled by Beehiiv.

Competitive economics make Beehiiv more attractive for operators who get meaningful paid subscribers. It takes a smaller revenue share than Substack's 10% fee and that makes Beehiiv more favorable.

When a newsletter has 10,000 free subscribers and 500 paid subscribers at $10 a month, gross revenue comes to $5,000 a month. The operator takes $4,500 at Substack's rate of 10%.

Under Beehiiv's flat-fee model for the Max plan (no per-transaction percentage charge), the operator takes the whole $5,000 minus the processing fee of 2.9% plus $0.30 from Stripe. As revenue rises, the math compounds.

Paid newsletter subscriptions come standard with ConvertKit's Creator Pro tier but the integration is less built in and takes more setup to put in place. Mailchimp has no native paid subscription feature.

Beehiiv Boosts: The Referral and Ad Network

Beehiiv Boosts is a two-sided network that lets newsletter operators earn revenue by recommending other newsletters to their subscribers, and grow their own audience through recommendations from other Beehiiv newsletters. The mechanism: when you publish a new issue, you can include a "Boost" that recommends another newsletter.[5]

If your subscriber clicks and subscribes to that newsletter, you earn a payment (typically $1-3 per new subscriber, set by the newsletter being boosted). Simultaneously, your newsletter can offer Boosts to other operators who want to grow.

This creates a network-effect marketplace that benefits from Beehiiv's growing community of newsletter operators.

A newsletter with 20,000 engaged subscribers in the personal finance niche can both earn revenue by boosting other finance newsletters and acquire new subscribers from newsletters in adjacent niches.

In 2025, some Beehiiv newsletter operators reported earning $3,000-8,000/month in Boost revenue alone.

Through the Beehiiv ad network, newsletter operators connect with advertisers targeting niche audiences. Newsletters in specific verticals (technology, finance, health, creator economy, business) get a meaningful revenue stream from monetising via curated ads without having to run a manual direct sponsorship program.

Ad placement, targeting and payment infrastructure are handled by Beehiiv. The operator gets revenue that is proportional to the size of its audience and its engagement metrics.

Neither Mailchimp nor ConvertKit has an equivalent native ad network or cross-newsletter referral system. Replicating these features on other platforms requires integrating separate tools (Sparkloop for referrals, direct sponsor outreach, Memberful or Stripe for paid subscriptions) and the associated overhead.[16]

Beehiiv's Analytics Advantage for Newsletter Operators

Beehiiv's analytics are built specifically for newsletter operators rather than generic email marketers. Among the metrics tracked are these:

  • Open rate by send time to identify when your audience is most engaged
  • Subscriber acquisition source so you know which growth channels produce your best readers
  • Paid conversion rate showing the funnel from free to paid subscriber
  • Churn analysis with reasons and cohort retention data
  • Boost performance showing earnings per recommendation

These metrics tell a newsletter operator what is actually working in their business. Mailchimp's analytics tell you click rates and open rates - useful for campaign optimization but not for managing a subscriber business.

Better analytics come from ConvertKit, especially for following the subscriber lifecycle through automated sequences. They are not set up around the reader-business model.


Deliverability: The Invisible Differentiator

Of all factors people most often weigh too little when picking an email platform, deliverability matters most. That is whether your emails get into subscribers' inboxes or end up in spam.

Since Google's February 2024 email sender rules required bulk email senders to authenticate with SPF, DKIM and DMARC and to keep spam rates below 0.1%, spam filtering has grown much more sophisticated. [14]

What it takes to be a legitimate email sender was raised by these changes and platform reputation became more important than individual sender reputation.

Beehiiv has developed a strong record on deliverability in part by building a platform that is designed specifically for newsletter operators who write content their subscribers want to read. Email providers see high engagement rates as a signal that mail from Beehiiv is welcomed and that advantage helps all senders on the platform.

ConvertKit's deliverability is strong and that shows both good technical infrastructure and a user base aimed at engaged audiences. Senders benefit from the platform's sender reputation when they send to opted-in lists that have high engagement.

Mailchimp's deliverability is good but more variable, partly because the platform's broader user base includes businesses running bulk promotional email that can depress platform-wide sender reputation. For most users Mailchimp deliverability is fine, but it is the weakest of the three for newsletter operators specifically.


Who Should Use What

Small Business with E-commerce

Mailchimp continues to be a good choice for small businesses that use Shopify or WooCommerce and want automated abandoned cart emails, order confirmations and product recommendation campaigns. E-commerce integrations there are mature and the templates are professional. The customer journey builder handles retail automation adequately as well.[6]

When email is a marketing channel along with social and paid ads rather than a main business model, Mailchimp's feature set is adequate. The brand is familiar enough that most team members will be able to use it without needing much training.

Course Creators, Bloggers, and Podcasters

ConvertKit was built with this audience in mind. Automation by tag lets you set up complex subscriber journeys for promoting courses, free challenges, book launches and product releases without help from a developer. The landing page builder and form tools are optimised for the list-building tactics that creators employ.

Deep integrations with platforms including Teachable, Kajabi, Gumroad and Stripe make your email platform work together with your product platform without any custom development. A generous free tier gives creators in the early stages a real advantage.

A specific use case where ConvertKit excels: a podcaster who also sells a $500 coaching program. New subscribers enter a welcome sequence. Based on what they click (links about the podcast, links about coaching, links about specific topics), they get tagged and added to relevant nurture sequences.

Prospects who have already shown interest get converted through the coaching program sequence. The whole system comes from ConvertKit's native design philosophy.

Newsletter Operators Building a Reader Business

Beehiiv is the clear choice for creators whose newsletter is the product rather than a marketing channel for another product.

When your revenue model depends on paid subscriptions, sponsorships and audience growth via referrals, Beehiiv's native infrastructure for all three gives a large advantage over putting together the same capability from separate tools.[11]

Coherent with the platform's design philosophy that great writing sent to an engaged audience makes a viable business is the product and it reflects that philosophy.

Morning Brew grew from 0 to 4 million subscribers using infrastructure that became Beehiiv's foundation. It is the clearest proof of concept.[9] Reproducible at a smaller scale is the playbook of a consistent editorial voice, a strong referral program and native ad monetisation.[18]

Established Businesses with Large Lists

Mailchimp Premium or enterprise email marketing platforms that come with advanced segmentation and compliance features (ActiveCampaign, Klaviyo, HubSpot) may suit larger organisations better when those organisations have complex needs.

When list sizes become very large, Mailchimp loses out to specialist e-commerce platforms such as Klaviyo for direct-to-consumer firms.[17] Large media organisations that build revenue from newsletters may do best with enterprise Beehiiv or a custom solution.


Pros and Cons

Mailchimp

Pros:

  • Most recognisable brand, widely understood by teams
  • Strong e-commerce integrations (Shopify, WooCommerce)
  • Large template library
  • 300+ third-party integrations
  • Customer Journey automation builder (Standard+)
  • Good A/B testing features
  • Predictive segmentation on higher tiers

Cons:

  • Free tier reduced significantly over time
  • Pricing scales steeply with list size
  • Charges per contact on multiple lists (inflated billing)
  • Creator-focused features weaker than ConvertKit
  • No native paid subscription feature
  • Interface can feel dated

ConvertKit (Kit)

Pros:

  • Designed specifically for creators
  • Generous free tier (10,000 subscribers)
  • Best visual automation builder
  • Excellent tag-based segmentation
  • Deep integrations with creator tools
  • Landing page builder is strong
  • Creator community and learning resources
  • Paid newsletter subscriptions (Pro tier)

Cons:

  • No native ad network or referral program like Beehiiv
  • Expensive at high subscriber counts
  • Interface less polished than some alternatives
  • E-commerce integrations depend on third parties
  • Some features only on higher plans

Beehiiv

Pros:

  • Built by newsletter industry veterans
  • Native paid subscription system
  • Beehiiv Boosts ad network and referral program
  • Newsletter-specific analytics
  • Clean, modern interface designed for writers
  • Flat-rate pricing more predictable at medium subscriber counts
  • Referral growth program native
  • Strong deliverability reputation

Cons:

  • Automation capabilities weaker than ConvertKit
  • Younger platform with smaller integration ecosystem
  • Less suitable for complex product funnel automation
  • Smaller community of learning resources
  • Free tier limited to 2,500 subscribers
  • Less suitable for e-commerce email marketing

Migration Considerations

Painful though it is, switching email platforms is not catastrophic if done correctly. Here are a few practical points.

Exporting your list from any platform produces a CSV of email addresses, names, and any tags or segments you have created. Most platforms import CSVs without issue. The painful part is rebuilding automations - every sequence, trigger, and conditional logic must be manually recreated in the new platform.

If you are migrating from Mailchimp to ConvertKit, the primary work is translating Mailchimp's list/segment model into ConvertKit's tag model. One Mailchimp segment becomes one or more ConvertKit tags. The mapping is usually straightforward.

When you migrate to Beehiiv, know that the subscriber experience changes. The newsletters have a publication feel instead of a promotional email feel. That is a design choice that serves readers well though it may surprise existing subscribers who are used to a different format.

Allow 30-60 days for migration, including a parallel-run period where you send to both platforms to check deliverability and engagement before fully switching.


Final Verdict

Choose Mailchimp if: your business is small and you use email mainly for promotions, newsletters and e-commerce automation and you want the most recognised platform with the biggest integration library and team familiarity.

Choose ConvertKit if: you are a creator building automated funnels to sell digital products, courses, or memberships, and you need the best tag-based automation and creator-specific integrations available at any price.

Choose Beehiiv if: Your newsletter is a standalone media business where paid subscriptions, sponsorship revenue and audience growth via referrals are your main ways to make money and you want native tools for all three without bringing in separate platforms.


Sources & Further Reading

  1. Mailchimp pricing -
  2. ConvertKit (Kit) pricing -
  3. Beehiiv pricing -
  4. ConvertKit free tier details - kit.com/features/free-plan
  5. Beehiiv Boosts documentation - support.beehiiv.com/boosts
  6. Mailchimp customer journey builder - mailchimp.com/features/customer-journey-builder
  7. ConvertKit automation documentation - help.kit.com/automations
  8. Beehiiv paid subscriptions overview -
  9. Morning Brew newsletter background -
  10. Email marketing benchmark report, Mailchimp, 2025
  11. 'The Creator Economy Email Stack,' Newsletter Operator, 2025
  12. ConvertKit rebrand to Kit announcement -
  13. Litmus State of Email Report 2025 -
  14. Google Email Sender Requirements 2024 -
  15. 'Email ROI Statistics' - Campaign Monitor 2025
  16. Sparkloop Newsletter Referral Platform Analysis 2025
  17. Klaviyo vs Mailchimp E-commerce Comparison - Klaviyo Blog 2025
  18. 'Building a Newsletter Business on Beehiiv' - Creator Economy Report 2025