Sara Okonkwo had been writing about personal finance for four years when her Twitter following hit 40,000 and she decided to start a newsletter. She chose Mailchimp because she had heard the name, spent a weekend setting up a template she liked, and sent her first email to the 200 people who signed up in the first week.
Within six months she had 8,000 subscribers. The newsletter was working. Then she tried to set up a welcome sequence (a series of four emails that new subscribers would automatically receive over two weeks) and found that multi-step automations on Mailchimp's free plan were not available.
She upgraded. Then her list hit 1,500 and the monthly cost doubled. She felt like she was being taxed for growing.
A friend who ran a cooking newsletter had made a different choice from the start. She had started on ConvertKit specifically because a friend who ran a cooking newsletter had told her the automation features were better suited to content creators.
She had set up a five-email welcome sequence in an afternoon, was selling a $27 recipe guide directly from her ConvertKit landing page, and was paying $25/month for a list of 800 subscribers.
When Sara eventually migrated her list from Mailchimp to Beehiiv (a process she described as "three hours of my life I am not getting back"), she gained a referral program, an ad network, and a public archive page she had not known she wanted until she saw what her newsletter could look like as a standalone publication.
Before you have built anything, the email marketing tool you choose sets your newsletter's ceiling. When growth becomes expensive is determined by the cost model. What you can automate and how is determined by the feature set. Who the product is actually optimized for is determined by the platformœs business model.
Name recognition leads most people to choose their initial option and they spend time later moving to something better suited. Every major option gets mapped here from newsletter-native platforms to enterprise automation suites. That way the choice can be made with full information the first time.
The best email marketing tool is the one your subscribers actually receive in their inbox. Everything else is features. But features do matter once you are past the basics.
Newsletter Platforms for Creators
Beehiiv
Alumni of the Morning Brew newsletter team built Beehiiv and the platform bears that out. It is designed around the model of a newsletter as a standalone publication business and not just an email list but a destination with its own URL, archive, subscriber base and multiple revenue streams.
The Newsletter Publication Page gives every Beehiiv newsletter a public-facing website where past issues are archived and discoverable via search. New subscribers can read previous issues before signing up. This is functionality that other platforms either charge extra for or leave to you to build in a separate website builder.
The Ad Network allows newsletters to earn revenue from display-style newsletter sponsorships sourced from Beehiiv's advertiser marketplace.[3]
Instead of emailing potential sponsors yourself, Beehiiv brings advertisers who want to target your audience's demographics to the surface and you choose whether to approve or decline each placement. The newsletter creator gets 85 percent of the revenue share.
Subscribers grow via a growth loop created by the Referral Program. Set up incentives for readers who bring in friends, free issues, downloadable material, merchandise or public recognition among them. Each subscriber receives a unique referral link. Signups coming from that link get tracked and credit gets assigned.
Once the initial subscriber base gets up to a few thousand readers, newsletters that use Beehiiv's referral program consistently report it as one of their top-converting growth channels.
Boosts allow paying to be recommended to subscribers of other Beehiiv newsletters. You set a cost-per-subscriber you are willing to pay, and Beehiiv surfaces your newsletter as a recommendation in relevant publications.
By niche and demand, the cost to acquire subscribers changes but most often it is lower than what it takes to get paid social media followers for newsletters.
The analytics are detailed and actionable. They cover per-issue open rate trends, subscriber growth by acquisition source, engagement at the segment level and reporting on churned subscribers.
Pricing starts free for up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends. Scaling costs $42 per month for unlimited subscribers and full monetization access and Max is $84 per month for advanced analytics, custom integrations and 3D analytics.
Best for newsletter creators who want a full publication platform instead of just email delivery. Growth tools, an ad network and a publication website work together to make Beehiiv the strongest platform for treating newsletters as standalone businesses.
Limitations. Less suitable for businesses that send promotional or transactional email along with editorial newsletters. Beehiiv does not focus on integrating e-commerce.
Substack
Zero upfront cost and built-in reader discovery make up Substack's defining advantage. The platform only earns when you do (10% of paid subscription revenue). That means the business model is set up to help newsletters grow and monetize.
The Recommendation Network is Substack's most powerful growth feature: when a reader subscribes to one newsletter, Substack suggests similar newsletters to follow.
For writers building an audience in a defined niche (personal finance, technology, culture, fiction), being surfaced to the existing reader base of adjacent publications creates organic growth that is difficult to replicate on other platforms.
Notes works as a social timeline within the Substack system. Short posts, links, quotes and reactions get passed among Substack readers and writers. That gives the email product a social layer inside the platform and makes engagement and discovery better there.
Reader apps for iOS, Android, and web provide a reading experience beyond the inbox. Subscribers can read your newsletter like they would read a media publication, browse your archive, and comment on posts without leaving the app.
Pricing is free for writers. Substack keeps 10% of all income from paid subscriptions.[4] There are extra Stripe processing fees of about 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction.
It fits writers starting a newsletter with zero upfront budget, creators who want built-in platform recommendations to grow their audience and publications that make most of their money from paid subscriptions.
At scale the 10% revenue cut compounds a great deal. A newsletter that brings in $10,000/month from paid subscriptions loses $1,000/month to Substack fees. That is about 24 months worth of Beehiiv's Scale plan every month.
There are few customization options and the platform has no advertising monetization, referral programs or sponsor marketplace.
ConvertKit / Kit
ConvertKit (rebranding as Kit in 2024) was built explicitly for the creator economy: bloggers, course creators, authors, podcasters, and independent educators who build businesses around direct audience relationships.[2]
The Visual Automation Builder displays email sequences as a flowchart with clear branching logic. When a subscriber joins a list, they enter a sequence. After email three, if they clicked the product link, they branch into a purchase sequence.
When they do not click, they go on through the nurture sequence. It is far easier to build and edit this logic in a visual map than to set it up as a list of text rules.
Sequences (drip campaigns) are the product's core strength. A welcome sequence, a course delivery sequence, an evergreen sales funnel - all are straightforward to configure with ConvertKit's tools.
Through mutual endorsement, the Creator Network lets you cross-promote with other ConvertKit creators. End your emails by recommending another creator's newsletter and they will promote yours too. That grows both lists.
Commerce allows digital products like ebooks, courses, templates and coaching packages to be sold directly from a ConvertKit-hosted page. Each purchase links to the subscriber's profile and this lets automatic tagging and sequence enrollment happen based on what has been bought.
Up to 1,000 subscribers come with unlimited sends and basic automations for free. The Creator plan is $25 per month for 1,000 subscribers and Creator Pro is $50 per month (it adds a newsletter referral system and subscriber scoring). Pricing rises with the size of the list.
Best for content creators setting up businesses around digital products, courses and direct audience relationships. Automation and sequencing work well with the drip-and-nurture approach that creator businesses commonly use.
Email template design options are more limited than those in Mailchimp or Flodesk. E-commerce and physical product integrations are weaker than what dedicated e-commerce email tools offer. Pricing per subscriber gets costly as the list grows larger.
Flodesk
Flat-rate pricing regardless of list size gives Flodesk a distinctive place in the email marketing world. A 500-subscriber list costs the same as a 500,000-subscriber list at $38 per month.
The platform's other distinguishing feature is visual design. Flodesk's templates are among the most aesthetically refined of any email platform - clean, editorial, grid-based layouts that feel closer to editorial design than traditional email marketing.
Skewing toward lifestyle, fashion, photography and personal brand aesthetics, the template library has seen strong adoption among photographers, designers and Instagram-native creators.
Checkout. On Flodesk-hosted pages, digital as well as physical products can be sold through Checkout and purchase-triggered automations are available.
Pricing: $38/month flat (email + forms), $64/month flat (email + forms + Checkout). No per-subscriber cost.
Visually oriented creators and small businesses that expect large list growth and need pricing certainty find this best suited to them. As the list gets bigger, the flat-rate model becomes a better value.
Automation and segmentation capabilities are less advanced here than at ActiveCampaign, Klaviyo or even ConvertKit. Complex behavioral triggers or e-commerce automation at scale are not supported.
Email Marketing Platforms for Business
Mailchimp
Mailchimp is the most widely used email marketing platform in the world, with over 13 million users.[1] This breadth translates into the largest third-party integration library of any email tool: over 300 native integrations with Shopify, WooCommerce, Stripe, Salesforce, Canva, and most other major business tools.
Journey Builder comes with the Standard plan and above and builds multi-step automation sequences that start from subscriber actions, date-based triggers and e-commerce events. Welcome journeys, post-purchase follow-ups, abandoned cart reminders as well as re-engagement campaigns can all be built on the visual journey canvas.
Audience Management. Segmentation tools in it let emails be targeted at specific subsets of the list by demographic, behavior, purchase history and custom tags. Working together with the journey builder, this lets fairly sophisticated lifecycle marketing be done without going over to a dedicated CRM platform.
Small businesses that lack dedicated design resources can use the Creative Assistant. This tool applies AI to create on-brand email designs from your existing logo and color palette and that helps them get professional-looking emails.
Pricing: free (500 contacts, 1,000 sends/month, limited automations), Essentials $13/month, Standard $20/month, Premium $350/month. Pricing scales steeply with list size - 50,000 contacts on the Standard plan is about $270/month; 100,000 contacts is about $480/month.
Best for small businesses that need a general-purpose email platform with lots of integrations, teams already working with tools in the Mailchimp integration ecosystem and e-commerce businesses that begin with email marketing.
Relative to alternatives, pricing at mid-to-large list sizes is expensive. The free tier has become restrictive. The platform has grown complex enough that navigating an increasingly layered interface is needed to find specific features.
ActiveCampaign
ActiveCampaign combines email marketing with a full CRM, positioning it for businesses that need to manage the entire customer relationship (from initial lead capture through sales to retention) in a single platform.[5]
Of all non-enterprise products, the Automation Builder ranks among the most powerful available. Complex multi-path journeys that adapt in real time to how subscribers behave can be built using conditions, branches, splits, goals and wait steps.
When a lead goes to the pricing page, it gets an email that differs from what a lead that downloaded a guide receives. A purchase by a customer adds that person to a retention sequence. When a customer churns, they go into a winback flow automatically.
Predictive Sending applies machine learning to find the best send time for each subscriber based on their past open patterns. Instead of sending to the whole list at 10am on Tuesday, each subscriber gets the email at the time that their history says they are most likely to open.
Site Tracking records every page a contact visits on your website and gives that behavioral data for segmentation and automation triggers. Someone who read your pricing page three times in a week can be automatically flagged for sales follow-up or put into a targeted email sequence.
CRM and Deal Pipelines let sales opportunities be managed with stage-based tracking, task assignment and email communication logged against each deal. When a company is B2B or has high-consideration sales, that removes the need for a separate CRM tool.
Pricing: Starter $29/month (1,000 contacts), Plus $49/month, Professional $149/month. Scales with contact count.
This product works best for B2B companies, service businesses with long sales cycles and businesses that need sophisticated behavioral automation and CRM functionality along with email marketing.
Klaviyo
Over 150,000 paying merchants use Klaviyo as the standard email and SMS platform for Shopify-based e-commerce.[6] The platform's dominance in this category shows real product-market fit. It was built from the ground up for the specific workflows of online retail.
Behavioral Triggers connect directly to Shopify and other e-commerce platforms. Browse abandonment (viewed a product, left without adding to cart), cart abandonment, post-purchase sequences, product replenishment reminders, and winback campaigns for customers who have not purchased in 90 days - all trigger automatically based on real-time behavioral data.
Revenue Attribution follows which emails directly came before a purchase and gives revenue credit to particular campaigns, flows and individual messages. When a welcome sequence brings in $4,200 a month in attributed revenue, it is clear that the configuration time is worth it.
Attribution transparency is one of Klaviyo's strongest differentiators from general email platforms.
Predictive Analytics takes each subscriber's purchase history into account to calculate an expected next order date, predicted lifetime value and churn risk score for that subscriber.
Proactive segmentation becomes possible from these predictions. Target high-lifetime-value customers with exclusive offers before any competitor does and find at-risk customers for retention campaigns before they lapse.
SMS Integration shares flows and segmentation with email in the same platform. An abandoned cart sequence can start with an email, follow up with a text message, and conclude with a final email - all in one automation flow.
Pricing: free (250 contacts), $45/month (1,000 contacts), $175/month (5,000 contacts), $415/month (20,000 contacts), $700/month (50,000 contacts).
Best for Shopify and e-commerce stores running real order volume, where built-in revenue attribution makes it easy to see the platform paying for itself in tracked sales.
Expensive at scale, overkill for businesses without much e-commerce transaction data and the cost per contact grows substantially as lists get larger. That is what the limitations are.
Brevo (formerly Sendinblue)
Unlimited contacts on all paid plans and pricing based on email sends per month instead of list size make Brevo's pricing model its main differentiator.[7] It costs the same to send one email monthly from a 500,000-contact list as from a 500-contact list with the same send frequency.
This model is particularly advantageous for businesses with large contact databases and lower send frequency - quarterly newsletters to a large customer base, annual re-engagement campaigns, or businesses that maintain large lists but communicate infrequently.
Multi-Channel messaging includes email, SMS, WhatsApp Business, and push notifications from a single platform and automation builder. Building an automation flow that sequences an email, then an SMS, then a WhatsApp message uses the same drag-and-drop interface for all channels.
Daily sends of up to 300 emails come with the free plan along with unlimited contacts. That is enough to support a growing list without any monthly fee and the only limit is the daily send volume.
Pricing: free (300 emails/day, unlimited contacts), Starter $25/month (20,000 emails/month), Business $65/month (100,000 emails/month).
This is best for businesses that have large contact lists and moderate send frequency. It is also for anyone who wants SMS and WhatsApp together with email in one platform and for organizations outside the US where WhatsApp is the main way to communicate.
Comparison Table
| Tool | Price | Free Tier | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mailchimp | From $13/month | 500 contacts | E-commerce, broad integrations, small business |
| ConvertKit/Kit | From $25/month | 1,000 subscribers | Creator businesses, digital products, sequences |
| Beehiiv | From $42/month | 2,500 subscribers | Newsletter publications, growth tools, ad network |
| Substack | Free + 10% revenue | Unlimited | Writers, paid subscriptions, discovery network |
| ActiveCampaign | From $29/month | None | CRM + email, B2B, complex automation |
| Klaviyo | From $45/month | 250 contacts | Shopify, e-commerce, behavioral triggers |
| Brevo | From $25/month | 300 emails/day | Large lists, multi-channel, international |
| Ghost | From $9/month | None | Membership publications, 0% revenue share |
| Drip | From $39/month | None | E-commerce automation, Klaviyo alternative |
| Flodesk | $38/month flat | None | Visual design, flat pricing, creators |
Ghost: The Self-Hosted Alternative
Ghost occupies a different category from the platforms above: it is a full content management system built for independent publications, with membership and newsletter functionality built in.
Where Substack and Beehiiv are platforms you publish on (your newsletter lives on their infrastructure, their domain, their ecosystem), Ghost is software you own and control. Your publication runs on your domain, your server, your data.
The Hosted Ghost plans cost $9 to $36 per month and they handle the infrastructure for you. But the ownership model is fundamentally different from what Mailchimp or Substack use.
The membership model allows free and paid tiers with complete control over pricing, access levels, and member data. Ghost takes 0% of subscription revenue - you pay only Stripe's payment processing fees (approximately 2.9% + $0.30).[8] For a newsletter earning $5,000/month in subscriptions, Ghost keeps nothing. Substack keeps $500.
Pricing: Starter $15/month (1,000 members), Publisher $29/month (1,000 members), Business $199/month (10,000 members).
Best for set up when an established publication has large paid subscription revenue and where the economics clearly favor ownership over Substack's free model that takes a 10% cut.
More setup is needed than for Substack or Beehiiv and there is no built-in discovery network. The growth tools on Beehiiv that are referral programs, ad network and Boosts are not present either.
Deliverability: The Issue Every Email Marketer Faces Eventually
Inevitably every conversation about email marketing gets to deliverability. That is the question of how many of your sends get into the inbox instead of the spam folder.
All the platforms above have strong deliverability infrastructure. Sender reputation is partly a function of what you do yourself. List hygiene, engagement rates and authentication setup count no matter which platform you use.
As of 2024, the non-negotiable technical requirements are that SPF, DKIM and DMARC records be properly set up for your sending domain. Bulk senders, which Google and Yahoo define as anyone sending over 5,000 emails per day, now need those authentication records in place.
Setup instructions are available from all major email platforms. Configure them or else a large share of your sends will go to spam.
Protecting deliverability at scale, here are the hygiene practices to list. Hard bounces should be removed right away since all platforms deal with that automatically. Suppress subscribers who have not opened in 180 days or run a re-engagement campaign and get rid of the non-responders. Purchased or scraped email lists should be avoided altogether.
A list with a 15% open rate sends a strong signal to inbox providers that your email is wanted. A list with a 2% open rate sends the opposite signal, affecting inbox placement for the active portion of your list.
Testing how an inbox places across major email providers can be done with tools such as GlockApps ($9+/month). Mail-Tester (free) gives a quick spam score check and Google Postmaster Tools (free) shows your domain specifically to Gmail users what its reputation is. That matters a great deal for newsletters aimed at consumers.
Choosing a Platform by Business Type
Solo newsletter creator: Begin on Beehiiv's free plan that covers 2,500 subscribers and move up to Scale ($42/month) as growth tools become relevant. Referrals through the referral program most often cover the subscription by reducing what it costs to acquire subscribers.
Until paid subscription revenue gets above about $500/month, Substack remains a rational choice if you like its discovery network or the zero upfront cost. That is when the 10% fee compares with Beehiiv's flat rate and becomes financially meaningful.
E-commerce business: Klaviyo is the choice if you are on Shopify and bringing in meaningful transaction volume. Behavioral triggers and revenue attribution make the cost worthwhile. Lower-volume stores or those on platforms other than Shopify go with ActiveCampaign or Drip.
Mailchimp Standard as a cost-effective alternative if advanced e-commerce automation is not yet needed.
B2B service business: ActiveCampaign handles the CRM integration and complex automation. What is strongest in a mid-market tool is the ability to follow individual contact behavior across many touchpoints and use that behavior to trigger emails.
Blogger or content creator selling digital products: ConvertKit for the sequence-focused automation, Creator Network cross-promotion, and built-in digital product sales. The platform is built for this exact model.
Large organization with existing large list: Brevo for the send-based pricing model that does not scale with contact count.
What the Research Shows
Research published by Litmus in 2025 found that email marketing generates an average return of $36 for every $1 spent - the highest ROI of any digital marketing channel measured in the study.[9]
Earlier research supports this finding and it shows both direct ownership of an email list with no algorithmic intermediary and the high intent of people who subscribed.
The same Litmus report showed that welcome email series bring in 51% more revenue per email than standard newsletters. This confirms the value of the automated sequences available in ConvertKit, ActiveCampaign and Klaviyo.
During a subscriber's first week on your list comes their highest-engagement period and an automated sequence that gives value right away turns what would otherwise take months of regular newsletters into days.
Newsletters running an active referral program grew 2.3 times faster than those without according to data from Beehiiv's 2025 State of Newsletter report. They acquired subscribers through referral at a median cost of $0.87 compared to $4 to $12 for paid social acquisition.
As list size grows, the referral program becomes more effective by compounding its effect. Larger lists mean more potential referrers that generate more referred subscribers and those in turn become referrers too.
Sources & Further Reading
- Mailchimp. "Email Marketing Platform." mailchimp.com.
- ConvertKit. "The creator marketing platform." convertkit.com.
- Beehiiv. "The newsletter platform built for growth." beehiiv.com.
- Substack. "Start a newsletter." substack.com.
- ActiveCampaign. "Marketing Automation." activecampaign.com.
- Klaviyo. "Email and SMS marketing." klaviyo.com.
- Brevo. "Email Marketing and CRM." brevo.com. View source
- Ghost. "Turn your audience into a business." ghost.org.
- Litmus. "State of Email Report 2025." litmus.com.








